Connect with us

UK

Key questions surround Keir Starmer’s future prospects

The prime minister’s situation is undoubtedly precarious, yet despite this, Labour MPs have chosen to maintain their support, leaving his long-term prospects uncertain.

Sir Keir Starmer faced his most challenging day as prime minister on Monday, but ultimately, it turned out to be a significant turning point in his favor.

Sir Keir Starmer

The gravity of the situation was clear, with Labour MPs contemplating a potential change in leadership, a prospect that Ed Miliband, the energy secretary, later described as a moment when they "looked over the precipice."

Miliband's remarks on BBC Breakfast highlighted the severity of the crisis that Sir Keir Starmer had to navigate.

The question of whether Labour MPs would continue to support Sir Keir Starmer was answered, at least for the time being.

However, numerous other questions remain unresolved, leaving uncertainty about the future.

For now, the immediate crisis appears to have been averted.

On Monday afternoon, Sir Keir Starmer's position seemed precarious, with Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, poised to call for his resignation, and many cabinet members remaining silent.

The situation was so dire that some officials in Downing Street and many in Westminster believed the prime minister's resignation was imminent.

It is essential to recall the fragility of the situation to appreciate the scale of Sir Keir Starmer's achievement in regaining control.

As Sarwar prepared to call for the prime minister's resignation in Glasgow, a crucial intervention came from David Lammy, the deputy prime minister, who posted on social media that Sir Keir Starmer's mandate should be respected.

This prompted a wave of similar messages from other cabinet members, ministers, MPs, and influential Labour figures.

The show of support resulted from an intense effort by Sir Keir Starmer's inner team, who worked to mobilize backing for the prime minister.

The team, operating from the cabinet room, contacted ministers and provided them with suggested statements to express their support for Sir Keir Starmer.

During a brief and tense call with Sarwar, Sir Keir Starmer reportedly asked a series of questions, including who would replace him and how Labour's prospects could be improved.

Similar questions were posed by Sir Keir Starmer's team to MPs who were wavering in their support.

At the midpoint of Monday, Sir Keir Starmer's position was uncertain, with his survival hanging in the balance.

Although he is no longer in immediate danger, the next challenges are likely to arise in the coming weeks.

It is crucial to understand the limitations of the endorsements Sir Keir Starmer received, as those close to him are aware of what they do and do not signify.

Some Labour members are baffled by the idea of replacing a leader who won a landslide victory and are angry about Sarwar's intervention.

A cabinet minister expressed outrage, stating that Sarwar's actions were unacceptable and that he should not have attempted to bring down the Labour government.

However, other ministers have privately indicated that their support for Sir Keir Starmer is conditional and time-limited.

For some, this means waiting until the May elections, which will have significant consequences for the Labour Party and the governance of devolved regions and councils.

Others believe that another crisis could emerge as early as the Gorton and Denton by-election, where Labour faces challenges from the Greens and Reform UK.

The interpretation of events depends on the individual's perspective, with some loyal to Sir Keir Starmer viewing the health secretary's actions through the lens of his potential ambition to become prime minister.

Wes Streeting arriving for Cabinet meeting surrounded by photographers
Wes Streeting told the BBC on Tuesday that the prime minister had his support

The health secretary's decision to release his WhatsApp messages with Lord Mandelson has been seen by some as a demonstration of leadership.

The health secretary has stated that he supports the prime minister and is focused on reducing waiting lists, a claim he repeated after the cabinet meeting.

However, his decision to release the WhatsApp messages outside of the formal process will not be emulated by other cabinet members, as the Cabinet Office has instructed them not to do so.

This instruction was sent to government ministers after the health secretary's actions, making it clear that his approach was not to be followed.

Some close to the prime minister have made the incendiary claim that the health secretary was behind Sarwar's intervention, a claim that has been denied.

Rumors circulated that a group of ministers supporting the health secretary would resign from the government before the Parliamentary Labour Party meeting, but this proved to be unfounded.

The fact that such rumors are circulating and that the health secretary's involvement is often suspected reflects the strained relationship between the prime minister and his health secretary.

Several Labour figures, including the health secretary, Angela Rayner, Shabana Mahmood, John Healey, and Ed Miliband, have been mentioned as potential alternatives to Sir Keir Starmer.

Angela Rayner at an event in Denton, surrounded by people
Angela Rayner is talked about as a possible successor to Keir Starmer in Downing Street

However, these individuals are often discussed in terms of their weaknesses rather than their strengths, which is a significant factor in Sir Keir Starmer's continued leadership.

The prime minister's position is secure, at least for the time being, due in part to the perceived flaws of potential alternatives.

The prime minister's chief of staff and director of communications departed on Sunday and Monday, respectively, marking the latest changes in a team that has experienced significant turnover.

Despite the challenges, the prime minister's team has received praise for its effective response to the crisis.

This may give Sir Keir Starmer reason to take his time in appointing permanent replacements for the departed staff members.

One imminent change is expected to be the departure of Sir Chris Wormald, the cabinet secretary and head of the civil service.

Sir Chris was appointed in December 2024, but concerns about his suitability for the role were raised shortly after his appointment.

Sir Keir Starmer is aware that, having parted ways with several appointees, he must now demonstrate his ability to make the necessary changes work.

A key issue at present is the extent to which the prime minister should adopt a more assertive approach. Miliband has argued that a bolder stance is necessary, a view that resonates with many Labour MPs who are seeking a more progressive policy direction.

Certain aspects of Sir Keir's policy platform have proven contentious among Labour MPs, with some decisions sparking significant debate. The departure of McSweeney, the former chief of staff, has raised questions about the impact of his influence on Sir Keir's decision-making process, and it remains to be seen whether a change in leadership will alter this dynamic.

The appointment of a new permanent chief of staff is likely to be a crucial factor in determining the direction of Sir Keir's leadership.

Although Labour MPs responded enthusiastically to Sir Keir's address at the Parliamentary Labour Party meeting on Monday, in which he vowed to oppose Reform and champion the interests of the country, potential policy disputes are still on the horizon, including proposed reforms to the SEND system.

A Labour MP expressed skepticism about Sir Keir's claims of past successes, noting that his record of conflict with the PLP tells a different story, and suggesting that this ongoing tension is unsustainable.

News

Family of Murder Victim Expresses Frustration Over Delayed Trial Scheduling

A 21-year-old woman, Chloe Mitchell, lost her life in June 2023, and a man is set to stand trial, facing a murder charge.

The family of Chloe Mitchell, a 21-year-old woman from Ballymena, is facing further uncertainty as they await the outcome of a trial for her alleged murderer, which may be impacted by an ongoing barristers' strike.

A close-up photo of Chloe Mitchell - a young woman with long, straight, fair hair -  smiling at the camera. She is wearing black-framed sunglasses with blue lenses on her head, which are partially visible.
Chloe Mitchell's remains were found eight days after she went missing in 2023

Chloe Mitchell's life was cut short in June 2023, when she was killed in an incident that has left her family and community in shock.

Brandon John Rainey, the man accused of her murder, is scheduled to stand trial on February 23, but the proceedings may be delayed due to the industrial action by defence barristers.

Following a recent court hearing to review trial arrangements, Nadine Mitchell, Chloe's sister, expressed her family's distress and frustration, telling BBC News NI that they are struggling to cope with the uncertainty.

Nadine Mitchell stated that her family has been left with no choice but to wait once again for a resolution, having already endured a prolonged period of anxiety and uncertainty.

The family's emotional turmoil is evident, with Nadine describing the experience as a prolonged period of distress, marked by sleepless nights and unbearable tension.

The Mitchell family is struggling to come to terms with their situation, which has left them feeling overwhelmed and distraught.

The current strike by defence barristers in Northern Ireland, which began last month, is a result of a long-standing dispute over legal aid fees, with barristers arguing that their fees have not kept pace with inflation.

The strike has brought almost all criminal trials in Northern Ireland to a standstill, with the exception of cases where the defendant does not require legal aid.

The Mitchell family has appealed for their case to be treated as an exception, allowing the trial to proceed as scheduled.

Chloe Mitchell, who was 21 at the time of her disappearance, was reported missing in early June 2023, prompting an extensive search operation.

Her remains were discovered about a week later, following a series of searches in the Ballymena area.

Brandon John Rainey was subsequently arrested and charged with Chloe's murder, which is alleged to have taken place between June 2 and June 5, 2023.

Rainey also faces a charge of attempting to prevent the lawful burial of a deceased body.

The dispute between barristers and the Department of Justice centres on the level of legal aid fees, which barristers claim have not increased since 2005.

A close-up of Brandon Rainey, a man with short, fair hair and stubble, looking at the camera.  He is sitting in a vehicle on a dark, wet night.
Brandon Rainey is accused of the murder of Chloe Mitchell

Barristers argue that the fees have not kept pace with inflation, resulting in a significant decrease in their real-terms value over the past 20 years.

The Criminal Bar Association (CBA) has warned that the low fees have created a crisis in the justice system, with many younger barristers refusing to take on legal aid cases due to the low rates of pay.

The CBA has described the strike as a "last resort" in their dispute with the Department of Justice, which has been ongoing for some time.

Despite an announced 16% increase in fees, which is set to take effect in mid-January, the strike has continued, with barristers arguing that the increase does not go far enough to address their concerns.

Chloe's father, George Mitchell, has previously appealed for an exception to be made in their case, allowing the trial to proceed despite the strike.

George Mitchell has argued that any delay to the trial would cause further trauma and distress for the families of victims.

He had invited Justice Minister Naomi Long to meet with him and his wife, Georgina, to discuss the matter further.

However, Minister Long has stated that it is not feasible to allow individual cases to proceed while the dispute over legal aid fees remains unresolved, citing ethical and practical concerns.

The minister has reiterated that the decision to grant exceptions lies with the CBA, which must weigh the competing demands of their members and the needs of the justice system.

Continue Reading

News

Peter Murrell faces allegations of misusing £459,000 in funds over 12 years

Allegations have been made that he bought various items, such as luxury goods, jewellery, cosmetics, two cars and a motorhome, in an improper manner.

Peter Murrell, the former chief executive of the Scottish National Party, is facing allegations of embezzling £459,000 from the party over a 12-year period.

Peter Murrell looking off to his right while sitting in a room. He is wearing a black suit, white shirt and dark coloured tie.
Peter Murrell is due to appear in court next Friday for a preliminary hearing

An indictment document obtained by BBC News outlines the case against Murrell, who is the estranged husband of former Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon.

The alleged embezzlement is said to have occurred between August 2010 and January 2023, according to the indictment.

It is claimed that Murrell used party funds to purchase luxury items, including jewellery, cosmetics, and vehicles, such as two cars and a motorhome.

The Scottish Sun was the first to report on the details of the indictment.

A preliminary hearing in the case is scheduled to take place at the High Court in Glasgow on Friday, 20 February, where Murrell is expected to appear.

During his initial court appearance at Edinburgh Sheriff Court, Murrell made no plea and was subsequently granted bail.

Murrell's arrest in 2023 was part of Operation Branchform, a police investigation into the SNP's funding and finances, which led to him being charged with embezzlement in April 2024.

A police van and a police officer outside Murrell's home in April 2023.
Murrell was arrested in 2023 as part of a probe into the SNP's finances

Although Sturgeon was questioned by police as part of the investigation, she is no longer considered a suspect.

BBC News has obtained a copy of the indictment against Murrell ahead of his upcoming court appearance.

It is worth noting that the indictment is subject to change until the case is heard in court and may be amended throughout the judicial process.

The indictment alleges that Murrell purchased a £124,550 motorhome for personal use and created false documents to justify the expense as a legitimate party expenditure.

Murrell is also accused of using £57,500 of party funds to buy a Jaguar I-PACE car in 2019, and falsifying an invoice to conceal the true nature of the purchase.

Furthermore, it is alleged that when the Jaguar was sold in 2021, Murrell deposited more than £47,000 into his personal bank account.

The indictment also claims that Murrell embezzled £16,489 from the SNP to partially fund the purchase of a Volkswagen Golf in 2016.

A list of over 80 retailers is included in the indictment, where Murrell allegedly made purchases totalling more than £159,000 between 2014 and 2022, using party credit or charge cards for personal expenses.

The retailers named in the indictment include Harrods, the Royal Mint, John Lewis, Homebase, and Argos, among others.

It is alleged that Murrell used SNP credit or charge cards to make these purchases and then inserted false or inaccurate accounting codes and descriptions into the party's accounting systems.

The indictment also accuses Murrell of making purchases worth over £81,600 through Amazon using the same method.

Murrell served as the SNP's chief executive for 22 years before his departure.

Murrell and Sturgeon were married in 2010, but announced their separation in January 2025, after being together for many years.

Continue Reading

News

Laos Methanol Poisoning Victim’s Brother Slams £135 Fines as Inadequate

A Lao court has handed down suspended sentences and imposed fines on 10 individuals connected to the deaths of six people at a hostel in the country.

A British tourist's brother has expressed outrage over the penalties given to 10 individuals connected to a mass methanol poisoning case, calling them "laughable".

A young man and woman sit in a pub or restaurant, smiling at the camera. He wears a high-necked zip-up fleece, while the woman wears a top with a black and white pattern reminiscent of an animal print.
Zak White's sister Simone died after drinking a shot laced with methanol in Laos

In November 2024, Simone White, 28, was among six people who lost their lives after consuming free shots at the Nana Backpacker Hostel in Vang Vieng, Laos.

The UK government has informed Simone's family that the 10 individuals charged with destroying evidence received suspended sentences and fines of $185 (£135) each, with no further action planned.

Zak White, Simone's brother, shared his concerns with BBC Newsbeat, stating that he doubts they will ever uncover the truth behind the incident or see a suitable punishment.

Simone, a trainee lawyer, and her childhood friend Bethany Clarke had reunited in Laos and spent a night at the hostel, where around 100 guests were offered free shots.

It is believed that these drinks were contaminated with methanol, a toxic substance commonly found in paint thinner, which is sometimes illicitly mixed with alcohol to reduce costs.

The next day, the friends fell ill and were eventually hospitalized, where Simone, from Orpington in south-east London, was placed on life support before passing away.

Since the incident, survivor Bethany and Simone's family have been advocating for increased awareness about the dangers of methanol and seeking answers from Laotian authorities.

A recent update from the UK Foreign Office, shared with relatives and seen by Newsbeat, reveals that 13 suspects were initially arrested in connection with the case.

According to the memo, 10 individuals linked to the Nana Hostel were convicted of destroying evidence.

The owner of the distillery suspected of supplying the methanol is still awaiting trial, as stated in the update.

Bethany, speaking to Newsbeat from Australia, expressed her feelings of "pure frustration" and "anger" upon hearing the news.

The developments suggest that it is unlikely anyone will be held criminally responsible for the deaths and life-altering injuries sustained by other tourists.

"Considering all the families involved, they all desire justice, but it seems they won't get it," Bethany says.

Zak tells Newsbeat that the family had prepared themselves for an unsatisfying conclusion to the case.

Two women, wearing all-black dresses, posing on of a balcony at night, surrounded by some plants. They're both smiling at the camera.
Bethany (left) met her friend Simone in Laos to explore the south-east Asian country

"We had a strong indication that justice might not be served," he says.

"The Laotian authorities have been uncooperative throughout the process, failing to provide timely updates or progress."

The Foreign Office stated that Laos' Ministry of Public Security had said the hostel could not reopen until the court proceedings were concluded, although it was unclear if this included the distillery owner's case.

However, Newsbeat discovered that the rebranded Paradise Hostel was listed on Booking.com and Agoda.

The business claimed to be under new ownership, but the Booking.com listing was removed after the platform detected "unusual activity" in its reviews.

A spokesperson stated that the listing was suspended temporarily for violating the platform's terms and conditions.

Agoda is investigating the listing after being contacted by Newsbeat.

Bethany says there are still unanswered questions about the case, including the identities of those charged and the lack of concrete information from Laotian authorities.

A young woman in a black vest top, hair tied back and sunglasses resting on her head, stands outside a white building with a crude "Nana Backpackers' Hostel" sign painted over the double doors at the front. The edge of a circular pool is just visible at the side of the shot.
Simone had been staying at the Nana Backpacker Hostel in Vang Vieng

"To this day, I still don't know exactly what's happening, despite speaking to several people," she says.

"I'm unsure what these charges entail or who they pertain to. We have no idea what's going on, and the law authorities aren't providing us with any information."

"The communication from the authorities is very limited, leaving us in the dark."

Foreign Office minister Hamish Falconer stated that the UK government "shares the disappointment of the families at this outcome and understands their frustration".

He added that the government has "clearly stated" its expectation of "robust action" from Laos against those who sell tainted alcohol and continues to raise the issue through its embassy.

The Foreign Office has previously expanded its methanol warnings to 27 high-risk countries and collaborated with content creators to raise awareness on social media.

However, both Zak and Bethany believe these efforts should be taken further.

Tune in to Newsbeat live at 12:45 and 17:45 weekdays, or listen back here.

A footer logo for BBC Newsbeat. It has the BBC logo and the word Newsbeat in white over a colorful background of violet, purple and orange shapes. At the bottom a black square reading "Listen on Sounds" is visible.
Continue Reading

Trending